Go to the store yourself with a pen and paper-
[QUOTE=Frannie; 1438147]Can you explain how food is cheaper in Los Charamicos, possibly giving some examples of prices of common commodity items compared to, say, the Playero supermarket? I don't spend much time there, but my impression is that colmado prices are at least 25% higher than supermarket prices on many basic items like milk, cheese, eggs, or juice, though it is true that one can buy fresh fruits cheaper from street vendors or direct off the truck. However when it comes to things like meat, milk, eggs, bread, rice, etc, the prices may not be quite as cheap as you think when you do the math. Part of the reason for this is that the colmado may sell small quantities, like 3 eggs, but at a high mark-up. And then a 6 gallon tank of propane for cooking is about 600 pesos plus transportation and delivery costs.
Yes, there is a lot of produce in the countryside, but it all belongs to someone (the farmer) and is not free for everyone to pick. Possibly you are confusing the DR with the Garden of Eden. Again, can you give some actual examples from experience of what you are talking about. I think there would be problems if the inhabitants of Los Charamicos started marauding into local agricultural areas in search of U-Pick food, though I sometimes suspect that some of the vendors who carry fruit on their heads in Sosua may have raided someone's back yard mango or avocado trees.
I have had a neighbor's child (age 6) raiding my fridge for yoghurt, which I had to put a stop to. Then he asked if he could have some water with sugar in it, apparently something he was used to getting at home. Ostensibly the family is not poor and has more than one source of income, but evidently food insecurity is never far away and you can't be sure that children are getting adequate nutrition as opposed to junk like sugar water.
Even the better off are not always THAT well off. For example my dentista has just one child of 5, but could not afford to send her for a summer course of swimming lessons in Puerto Plata although she has a full time job for government as a prison dentist plus a private practice in the afternoons in a dental office shared with her sister. (Of course she does not give her child sugar water either.)
As I have said before, with children it is not always simply a question of whether they will actually starve do death, but whether they will get adequate nutrition to grow up healthy and become productive adults.
However nothing I am saying here has any particular bearing on whether a particular chica was lying to a particular visitor on a particular occasion. I know that chicas may tell lies to extract money, but I think it is important for mongers to understand that the chicas they are dealing with are not on the same economic footing as themselves or they people they know back home, and that food insecurity is a real concern for many.[/QUOTE]You seem to be the expert on everything when it comes to supporting the "poor dominican people" theme-Take a walk to Charamico-go to the markets there see how much they want for their produce-I go I know-cost me 400 pesos for a weeks worth of groceries for breakfast and lunch. Don't believe me I don't really care. Pina 4 for 100 pesos eggs 6 pesos each-and another thing alot of the people are self sufficient-have farms.
I agree, It's a matter of degree.
[QUOTE=Combo;1438369]It's a matter of degree. He pretty much demonstrated to her that he isn't a naive clown by giving her 1000 pesos, a fairly modest amount. A 200 propina on top of that (if she gave good service) is reasonable. I do agree with you that the typical overpaying monger sets himself up when he pays her "asking price." A precedent is set that if he doesn't give into her financial demands, she will then turn off the affection. But I don't think that's what Frannie was involved in with this particular chica. It seems pretty obvious he was the one in control of the exchange.[/QUOTE]It wasnt stated clearly whether or not they agreed to 1000 pesos. But the fact is, she asked for more money. That indicates IMO, she wasnt satisfied with only 1000 pesos. Whats further interesting is. If she indeed gave good service as you suggested, he didn't offer her the 200 pesos in the 1st place. She had to ask him for the 200 pesos. That means he did not intend to give her more money.
It appears that when he gave the chica 200 pesos extra, he surmised that he was going to get better performance than what he got for the 1000 pesos. That the 200 pesos extra was money well spent. All I'm saying is, that perspective is flawed. There was no agreement from the chica for that to happen. IMO, when it comes to being in control. Control is shared, but not necessarily equal. And you are right, it is a matter of degree. The chica is in control of the quality of the performance, and her time. She also has some indirect control by her powers to manipulate a monger to meet or exceed her expectations when it comes to getting compensation. Thats done simply by adjusting her mood to the monger so he will react accordingly. The monger is mainly in control of his money. As long as a monger engages the chica, she is the one that has more control in the encounter. IMO.