Accept it for what it is.
I've recently come to the decision to remain here in the Philippines, after struggling for a couple of years with the issue. What ultimately decided the issue for me is the fact that I have a nice life here; one that for the most part I enjoy, and in general, I like Filipinos. In the process of arriving at this decision, I accepted the conclusion that to life happily here, you have to accept the place on its own terms, working out for yourself the equation of whether the upsides outweigh the negative factors. To me, this means that it's unrproductive to compare the Philippines to other countries in terms of corruption, the legal system, standards of living, poverty indices, economic growth or other variables. What's the difference? Ultimately, you either like the place or you don't. You enjoy staying here or you don't. It's recognizing the fact that as a foreigner, what you think doesn't matter much in the more general meta context. You're not going to change anything. Thus, to me, whether corruption is "minor league" here compared to the US or Western European countries is totally irrelevant. I can't change the system in the US (where I'm a citizen) or here, where I'm not. The ultimate question is where I'd rather live. Having made the decision, I no longer feel that I need to justify it.
GE
Thanks RK. Nearly fell out of my academic chair when I read Frits' stuff
[QUOTE=Red Kilt;1322600]Apart from the huge difference in resources (teacher quality, learning materials, equipment and buildings) , most kids leave their US school with a basic education. In the Philippines, outstanding students manage to learn despite the experience of schooling but the majority fall through the cracks and leave school (and often College) as unemployable semi-adults.[/QUOTE]Not sure where to start here. Methinks Frits is harking back to his own high school days to make a comparison. Filipine high schools are little like american high schools. College prep american students will have had: calculus, AP english, AP history. 2-4 years of a foreign language. 1+ years of a visual / performing art, and 2 or more of: bio / physics / chemistry. Similar filipine students might have had: algebra / geometry. Please see the University of California A-G requirements at:
[url]http://universityofcalifornia.edu/admissions/freshman/requirements/a-g-requirements/index.html[/url]
And keep in mind these are minimums for entrance consideration; most students go far beyond because of competitiveness. My 3-semester college calculus textbook was thicker than your fist and cost $165, 30 years ago. A fourth semester on differential equations is common in pretty much every american college, including 2-year 'junior' colleges; yet I'd guess unheard of in all but a few Filipino colleges. One of my son's aerodynamics textbooks is as thick as my outstretched hand and costs over $200, again I'd bet this is fairly unheard of in phils. Also, regarding HS standards, the New York Regent's exams:
[I]Regents Examinations are statewide standardized examinations in core high school subjects required for a Regents Diploma in New York State. In the past, Regents Diplomas were optional and typically offered for college bound students. In recent years graduation requirements have been made more stringent, and currently all students are required to receive a Regents Diploma, and therefore most students, with some limited exceptions, are required to take the Regents Examinations. To graduate, students are required to have earned appropriate credits in a number of specific subjects by passing year-long or half-year courses, after which they must pass Regents Examinations in some of the subject areas. For higher achieving students, a Regents with Advanced Designation and Honors designations are also offered. [/I]
[QUOTE=Red Kilt;1322600]I am an Aussie so I am not defending the US system but after having worked at close proximity with the Philippines education system (note the correct spelling of "Philippines" Frits) for the past 15 years and having spent 6 months on sabbatical leave on the east coast of the USA in the mid-90s I can quite comfortably state that the US education system is MUCH more advanced than that of the Philippines, especially if we use [B]access[/B] and [B]equity[/B] as key indicators.[/QUOTE]Ya lets talk about that access / equity thing. American schools teach a population that is very heterogeneous in many ways. Most other places on earth teach a very homogenous population in many ways. At my daughter's old HS there were 16 spoken languages (9 at one of my son's HS). American schools mix multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, and multi-colored students. At many american schools are a smattering of major religions (hindi, sikh, christian, islamics, taoists, buddhists, hmongs, jews) all in the same school. Rival gang affiliations (often associated with a father's incarceration) is in the mix. Where I grew up, there was a european mix of names in the neighborhood: french, german, greek, etc, but we spoke english. In my current abode in the western US, my daughter's friends came over to swim in the pool and they were: laotian, guatemalan, arabic, mexican, peruvian, Filipino, viet, canadian, and redneck haha, etc. Filipino schools don't have to worry about teaching that kind of diversity. That should cover equity.
Access: when was the last time you saw a filipine elementary or HS install elevators or special toilets because a new student enrolled mid-year in a wheelchair? Its the law in the US. The law says US schools must accommodate every student. In many places on the planet, the disabled are not allowed entry.
Don't complicate a simple issue
Hey Skip and WR,
Don't complicate matters with your broad international perspectives and bring college / university standards into it. It has already sidetracked the basic issue.
Frits said high schools in US and the Philippines were the same.
I think only a few minutes with some very basic performance indicator data, a short video and a compilation of photos taken from a sample of schools in both countries would quickly establish that his statement is silly.
Enough! Leave out all the University ranking stuff.
This is the Manila thread where we talk about opportunities to exploit our hobbies in Manila.
Oops it's late. I need to get to an appointment.